You are hereBelgian eID Cards

Belgian eID Cards


By chri - Posted on 30 September 2008

As a reaction on the eID comments of Philip and Guy.

So, if they pushed on data retention laws and interceptable cell phones, what would be the odds of them giving up control of your keys?

This is not completely correct with the Belgian eID. Let me explain. The government indeed generates the private keys on separate machines before uploading them to the card. This is (they say) for performance reasons and they (they say) delete the original private keys completely from the systems. This is indeed a practice that is contrary to all the PKI principles. I won't discuss this part.
But if you analyze the eID card a little better (check my post) you will see that the card contains two types of certificates. One for Authentication and one for Signature. These certificates are not usable for data encryption.
Knowing that the government can create their own certificates (you do thrust them as a CA) they can easily generate new certificates that contain 'valid' data. There is no need to keep the private keys of the population to perform identity hijacking.

Why you should distrust your Belgian eID card?

When speaking about the eID it's important to specify what part you are talking about. Is it the SmartCard or is it about the Government-issued-certificates?
The SmartCard contains some empty slots (check my post) and that you can upload or generate your own private keys on the card. These keys can be considered secure as long as the SmartCard hasn't been cracked.

Edit: When I speak about trust it is about 'relative trust' depending on the environment and situation. Security is not binary, it's never either a 1 or a 0

Even though I realise that it's only signature certificates that they provide, it would be sufficient to impersonate me in important transactions.

Not only do I suspect the government to keep copies of said keys, but I also do not trust them to keep those keys safe.

"The SmartCard contains some empty slots"
=> opensc can connect more than one smart card. Empty slots match the number of smart card reader which can be connected.

In reply to your macosx smart card logon, you should know that you can do the same with vista :
http://eidauthenticate.sourceforge.net

Regards,
Vincent

I Love Belgium... and you?

About Me
GnuPG Public Key Still More LinkedIn profile
Photos
Projects
WeIDS 2.0 Linux Lessons WiFi Auth Project
Documentation
Acer Aspire 2012 WLMi Acer TM 4002 WLMi IR-receiver (Win)(NL)
Links
Ubuntu Belgium Planet Grep

FOSDEM BruCON Profoss hacker emblem www.cacert.org Get OpenOffice Get Firefox Get Thunderbird